Why should you schedule an appointment with us?

Sherri Stewart, Agent


  • Licensed insurance agent since 1992
  • Passionate about helping employers, seniors and individuals choose the best possible products for their insurance needs through one-on-one guidance
  • An expert at helping people with their claim issues should a problem arise after the sale
  • A compassionate person and a good listener which helps me better understand your needs

Tammy Rentschler, CSR


  • Joined American Central Insurance Services in August 2017 
  • Graduated from Lakeland College with a data processing degree 
  • Licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health 
  • Worked for 14 years in the financial industry as a branch office administrator and office manager for an independent insurance agent 
  • Member of Lakeland College Alumni Board, Costume Director at First Christian Church of Mattoon and a Co-Chairman of local Relay for Life Event in Mattoon for over 15 years
  • Hobbies include sewing and fitness classes of Aqua Zumba at the Mattoon YWCA
  • Married and has 2 daughters

Contact Us

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

Sherri Stewart - Insurance Broker @ American Centr

304 E Southline Rd, Ste A, Tuscola, IL 61953

(217) 599-1202


Drop us a line!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.